Pdf the proper statement and assessment of russells theory depends on ones. The presuppositions of soft triggers are obligatory scalar implicatures. In short, russell argued that the syntactic form of descriptions phrases that took the form of the aardvark and an aardvark is misleading, as it does not correlate their logical and. There are three main motivations for the theory of descriptions. In his paper on denoting 1905, the english philosopher bertrand russell. Philosophy of language russells theory of descriptions britannica. Bertrand russell by individual philosopher philosophy. Rtd is used to analyze sentences in which definite descriptions occur in. The theory of descriptions is the philosopher bertrand russell s most significant contribution to the philosophy of language. This method of analysis, first introduced by russell in his article on denoting 1905, translates propositions containing definite descriptions e. In this paper russell took himself to be inaugurating a program of analysis that.
Stephen neale discusses bertrand russells famous theory of descriptions and some of the philosophical issues surrounding it involving the nature of language. Bertrand russells theory of descriptions rtd can be appreciated against the background of russells view about the connections between language and the. In fact, while russell s theory of descriptions is still widely accepted, many contemporary philosophers of language believe russell was wrong to claim that proper names are. It presents, in outline, russells theory of descriptions and the motivations underlying it. In this excerpt, russell presents a semantic theory a theory of meaning for a particular type of expression. He waited until he collected a large number of observations that. Bertrand arthur william russell 18721970 was a british philosopher, logician, essayist and social critic best known for his work in mathematical logic and analytic philosophy. Russell s own answer to the puzzle came in the form of a theory of types. This question calls for an ambitious empirical research program, but we can. Russells own solution, which uses definite descriptions and mixes semantics and epistemology is. In bertrand russell has been through its socalled theory of descriptions.
It is also known as russell s theory of descriptions commonly abbreviated as rtd. Bertrand russells inductivist turkey look back in respect. Now since the same kind of difficulty seems to arise for the russellian theory. It implies that there is a certain something, and that there is only one such thing. Bertrand russell 1911 the philosophical importance of mathematical logic. What i affirm is, according to the theory i advocate. Another look at bertrand russells theory of descriptions.
Russell 1919, writing in prison, made the following now famous declaration of. Definite descriptions and negative existential quantifiers springerlink. Russells theory of descriptions lawrence university. The indefinite article a contains only the first element. Bertrand arthur william russell 3rd earl russell aka sir bertrand russell 1872 1970 was a british philosopher, logician, mathematician and historian he is generally credited with being one of the founders of analytic philosophy, and almost all the. Bertrand russell s theory of descriptions rtd can be appreciated against the background of russell s view about the connections between language and the world, although this view is not itself a part of the theory. Of course, the suggestion that ordinary proper names are not referring expressions is counterintuitive. Referential uses of descriptions raise familiar problems for the theory, to which there are. Bertrand russell tried to demonstrate that the referential theory of meaning is false concerning definite descriptions and. Now each these propositions can be properly settled because they amount to a conjunction in which the first proposition is false that there is a present king of france. Description and explanation of the major themes of bertrand russell 18721970. Consider, for instance, the hoary problem of nonbeing. Logically, any statement that is a conjunction of propositions is false if any one of the conjuncts is false.
His most influential contributions include his championing of logicism the view that mathematics is in some important sense reducible to logic, his refining of. Russell delimits definite descriptions from indefinite ones, saying that the former take the form the soandso while the latter take the form a soandso. The theory of descriptions is the philosopher bertrand russells most significant contribution to the philosophy of language. Being a good inductivist turkey he did not jump to conclusions. Russells theory of definite descriptions philosophy of. Bertrand russells theory of descriptions rtd can be appreciated against the. Bertrand russell from wikipedia the turkey found that, on his first morning at the turkey farm, he was fed at 9 a. Philosophy of language russells theory of descriptions.
Russell s theory of descriptions the power of frege s logic to dispel philosophical problems was immediately recognized. The latter way was invented by bertrand russell and is known as the theory of definite descriptions and derived from it is also the description theory of proper. The problem in the paradox, he reasoned, is that we are confusing a description of sets of numbers with a description of. So we can now apply russell s theory of descriptions. An explication of bertrand russell s solutions to the puzzles of the bald king of france and the problem of negative existentials through the use of his theory of definite descriptions. This accessible literary criticism is perfect for anyone faced with bertrand russell 18721970 essays, papers, tests, exams, or for anyone who needs to create a bertrand russell 18721970 lesson plan. In bertrand russells hands, for example, the analysis of descriptions became a. Does strawsons critique of the theory of definite descriptions. Freges logic and type theory relevant to russells project. Russell and frege on the logic of functions new prairie press. Bertrand russell s entry on the theory of knowledge for the 1926 edition of the encyclopaedia britannica. Pdf russells theory of definite descriptions researchgate.
805 577 792 1522 284 862 343 625 434 1596 751 1458 1065 1268 24 1136 1318 692 634 1619 1620 226 642 1217 1048 921 1210 207 1100 1040 1536 458 1281 328 846 1463 289 729 928 307 1155 1387 641 249 199 1219